Health care unions back debt reform push in MN Legislature

Members of the Minnesota Nurses Association support a bill that would reform laws around medical and other types of debt.

Jennifer Schultz has been cancer free for over two years, but being free from the debt she’s amassed in her battles with the illness feels a long way off for the four-time survivor from St. Paul.

“Sometimes it feels like I’m in a constant cycle of medical debt,” Schultz told labor, faith and community activists who rallied April 15 in the Capitol rotunda.

“There are weeks when I have to choose between filling up my gas tank, buying groceries for myself and making a full payment toward my cancer bills.”

Schultz and other activists applauded a package of debt-related reforms advancing through the DFL-controlled Legislature this session.

Proponents of the Minnesota Debt Fairness Act, including faith-based organizations, health care workers’ unions and Attorney General Keith Ellison, called it a first step toward correcting a debt collection system that needlessly forces families across the state into poverty.

Pastor James Alberts of Higher Ground Church of God in Christ in St. Cloud – one of three religious leaders who spoke at the rally –  said debt forgiveness is value shared among faith communities, from Judaism and Islam to Christianity. Alberts pointed to the Lord’s Prayer, which asks for “forgiveness of debts as we forgive our debtors.”

“Mercy and forgiveness are missing in our debt collection system, and here in Minnesota it is time to act in every way we can to fix this,” he said. “We must pass debt relief now.”

Medical debt is the Minnesota Debt Fairness Act’s primary focus, and members of the Minnesota Nurses Association were well represented at the rally. Jennifer Michelson, a retired United Hospital nurse, said MNA members see the strain of medical debt firsthand.

“I didn’t take care of very many patients who could cover the full cost of the care they received,” she said. “It’s hard for our patients to heal if their energy is going toward worrying about medical bills that they can’t afford to pay, or how their families will take care of it if they pass away.”

The proposed legislation would repeal a state law that automatically transfers medical debt to a patient’s spouse. In Minnesota, medical debt is the only kind of debt transferred in this way.

The Minnesota Debt Fairness Act would also ban medical providers from refusing care – or threatening to do so – to a patient with outstanding bills. A study by the Peterson Center on Health Care found 60% of people with medical debt have deferred care to avoid going further into the red.

Additionally, health providers or their collections agents would be barred from reporting patients’ debt to credit bureaus because, Schultz said, bad credit “shouldn’t be a side effect of getting sick.”

Other provisions in the bill would apply more broadly to the state’s debt collection system, making adjustments based on income levels to the maximum percentage of someone’s wages that creditors can garnish – and shielding the last $4,000 in Minnesotans’ bank accounts from garnishment.

“This is so you don’t go to the grocery store to buy groceries for your family and find out you have zero dollars left in your account,” Rep. Liz Reyer (D-Eagan) said. “We know this happens. It’s not right.”

After the rally, members of the House voted to advance a commerce policy bill that included the Minnesota Debt Fairness Act’s key provisions.

But the Senate’s companion bill, passed earlier in the session, did not address debt reform, meaning representatives of the two chambers need a conference committee to settle on a final bill to send to Gov. Tim Walz before lawmakers’ deadline to adjourn May 20.

Attorney General Ellison urged activists at the rally to keep the issue on their representatives’ agenda.

“This is a moral issue,” he said. “It’s not just a legal issue, it’s not just a political issue, it’s a moral imperative to pass this bill. Those signs that you brought, don’t just leave them here. Take that sign with you and put it up somewhere people can see it…

“I want the world to know that we’re passing this bill today, and this is not the end of it.”

Nurses buy – and forgive – $2.6 million in medical debt for Minnesotans

MNA President Mary Turner (L) and Executive Director Rose Roach rip up medical debt for 1,800 Minnesotans.

Twin Cities community members overwhelmingly supported Allina nurses during their historic strike last year. Today, members of the Minnesota Nurses Association offered a thank-you gift for that support, purchasing and forgiving the past-due accounts of 1,800 families facing a combined $2.6 million in medical debt.

MNA, a union of more than 20,000 registered nurses, located and acquired the accounts with help from RIP Medical Debt, a New York-based non-profit. Like a collection agency, the organization buys medical debt at a fraction of its value.

Rather than aggressively pursuing the debt it purchased, though, MNA immediately forgave it.

“Nurses are happy to allow these families to be free of their debt,” MNA President Mary Turner said. “They’ve had this medical debt hanging over their heads for two years or more.  It’s cost them their credit, pushed them toward bankruptcy and hurt them in so many ways.”

MNA paid $28,000 for the $2.6 million balance.

Names and other details regarding the forgiven accounts will remain private, but one Minnesotan struggling to pay down medical debt, Debra Puchala, agreed to tell her story during a press conference at MNA’s headquarters in St. Paul this morning.

Debra Puchala speaks about her battle to get out of medical debt. (MNA photos by Chris Reinke)

After undergoing hip replacement surgery in September 2015 and shoulder surgery the following year, Puchala owes various medical providers more than $5,000.

“The bills kept coming,” she said. “When you have surgery, you know, you get more than one bill, and … everybody wants their money right away. I was told that I was going too slow.”

One of her six bills wound up in collection, and as a result, Puchala said, “I can’t make a regular medical appointment. I have to go to either urgent care or, if it gets bad, emergency.”

In January 2017, faced with the prospect of tacking on another $5,000 to her debt load before reaching the insurance plan’s deductible, Puchala dropped out of her physical therapy regimen, and she continues to put off knee replacement surgery, she said, “because I can’t take on the debt.”

MNA has long derided the U.S. health care system for forcing patients like Puchala into consumer decisions that pit their wellness against their other needs, like food and rent.

Medical debt is the No. 1 cause of bankruptcy in the U.S. Past due accounts to health care providers are cited in 62 percent of bankruptcy cases, and bad debt to medical providers is expected to top $200 billion by 2019.

“Medical bills are now the No. 1 reason people are contacted by debt collectors,” Minnesota Attorney General Lori Swanson said at the MNA press conference. “Even people with health insurance face unpaid medical bills due to the very high deductibles in many insurance policies.

“The Minnesota Nurses Association is generous to have relieved people from the weight of this debt.”

The union was inspired to acquire Minnesotans’ medical debt after several members watched a report on HBO’s “Last Week Tonight with John Oliver” about RIP Medical Debt.

“We’d had many discussions about how to repay the community for what they gave nurses during the strike,” Turner said. “The John Oliver show inspired us, and we decided to see if we could do the same thing. MNA is grateful to RIP Medical Debt for helping us make this happen.”

About 5,000 MNA members who work at Abbott Northwestern, Mercy, United and Unity hospitals and Phillips Eye Institute spent nearly a month and a half on the picket line last year in a campaign to keep their high-quality health insurance, improve workplace safety and protect patients from staffing shortages.