Striking nurses weigh contract proposal in advance of voting Monday

MNA spokesperson Angela Becchetti, a nurse at Abbott Northwestern Hospital, talks with media about Allina's most recent proposal to striking nurses.

MNA spokesperson Angela Becchetti, a nurse at Abbott Northwestern Hospital, talks with media about Allina’s most recent proposal to striking nurses.

Striking nurses will vote Monday on a three-year contract proposal from Allina that makes some gains on staffing and safety – two of their top issues – but wasn’t good enough to win a recommendation from the union’s bargaining team.

Nurses fought tooth and nail with Allina over the course of mediated talks this week that spanned three days but “felt much longer than that,” United Hospital nurse and bargaining team member Bunny Engeldorf said at a press conference in Minneapolis today.

“It was not easy to leave that table,” she added, without a tentative agreement they could recommend, but all 15 members of the bargaining team agreed Allina nurses deserve an opportunity to vote.

Angela Becchetti, a nurse at Abbott Northwestern Hospital and union spokesperson, said negotiators are “confident nurses will make the best informed decision come Monday.”

More than 4,000 members of the Minnesota Nurses Association have been on strike at five Allina facilities in the Twin Cities area since Labor Day.

Voting Monday will take place at four locations close to the picket lines outside United Hospital in St. Paul, Abbott Northwestern and Phillips Eye Institute in Minneapolis, Mercy Hospital in Coon Rapids and Unity Hospital in Fridley. Nurses already are able to review the 41-page contract proposal, and the union will hold several meetings to answer questions and discuss the terms.

In talks that began Tuesday, nurses were finally able to get Allina to address their staffing concerns. The provider agreed to establish a labor-management team to evaluate whether charge nurses should be assigned patients. Combined with provisions to improve nurses’ safety on the job, the staffing language represents some progress on “what we wanted this contract to address,” Engeldorf said.

Allina’s top priority in contract negotiations, which began in February, was eliminating nurses’ preferred, quality health insurance plans and moving them into the provider’s corporate plans.

Nurses eventually relented, but they continued to fight for language assuring their benefits would not diminish over the course of the contract. They came away with a partial victory, negotiators said, noting that it was an improvement on what Allina offered in talks before the strike began.

MNA Executive Director Rose Roach said bargaining issues with Allina felt “like dealing with molasses,” and she credited the 15 members of the union’s bargaining team for having “pushed as far as they could.”

If a majority votes to reject the proposal Monday, the strike will continue. If members vote to accept, union leaders and Allina will begin discussing how the 4,000-plus strikers return to work.

Until the two sides reach a settlement, picket lines will stay up, and union negotiators were quick to dispel any notion that nurses would begin crossing the line before then. Striking nurses are set to lose their employer-provided health insurance tomorrow.

“Allina thinks Oct. 1 is a deadline for their nurses,” Becchetti said. “It’s not. We’re calling it Red October. We’ll be out here in full force.”

Regardless of how the vote goes, one thing is already clear: The relationship between Allina Health and its nurses is at an all-time low.

“The level of disrespect they have shown for their greatest ally, the nurses, has cost them something that can’t be put on a balance sheet,” Roach said.

Laser focused on cutting health care, Allina turns deaf ear to nurses’ safety concerns

Abbott Northwestern nurse and MNA spokesperson Angel Becchetti speaks at a press conference on nurses' safety proposals.

Abbott Northwestern nurse and MNA spokesperson Angela Becchetti calls on Allina to respond to nurses’ proposals to improve their safety on the job.

 

When Celeste Kopacek’s patient in the neuroscience unit at Abbott Northwestern Hospital told her he was going home to get his gun and would come back to find her, she reported the threat to Allina security.

“They told me to call back if he showed up,” Kopacek said.

Since contract negotiations with Allina began in February, nurses at five metro-area Allina facilities have made several proposals aimed at improving their safety on the job.

Erinn Olson (L) and Celeste Kopacek display a partial list of the attacks Kopacek has suffered while working as an Abbott nurse.

Erinn Olson (L) and Celeste Kopacek display a partial list of the attacks Kopacek has suffered while working as an Abbott nurse.

Allina has refused to respond to those proposals, nurses said at press conference today outside Abbott Northwestern. Instead, the not-for-profit corporation has focused almost exclusively on slashing nurses’ health insurance.

“We’ve made a compromise on their issue,” Abbott Northwestern nurse Angela Becchetti said, referencing steep concessions nurses accepted in last-ditch negotiations before beginning their open-ended strike Sept. 5. “They haven’t made a compromise on ours.”

Nurses want a heightened security presence in their facilities to reduce response times when patients become violent or dangerous. Nurses have seen an uptick in such incidents over the last 10 years, in part, because of untreated mental illness, opioid addiction and other substance-abuse issues.

Nurses also want Allina to provide counseling and paid time off to nurses who are victims of violent incidents, as well as more training in how to diffuse them before they begin.

“We need more than two hours of training,” said Erinn Olson, Kopacek’s colleague in the Abbott neuroscience unit.

About 4,700 Allina nurses are on strike at Abbott Northwestern, United, Unity and Mercy hospitals, as well as Phillips Eye Institute.

“Every single one of them has at least five stories,” Kopacek said, of being attacked or threatened on the job. “To not feel safe at work is unacceptable.”

On Labor Day, nearly 5,000 Allina nurses begin open-ended strike (photos & video)

Picketers walk the sidewalk outside United Hospital in St. Paul shortly after MNA's strike began on Labor Day.

Picketers walk the sidewalk outside United Hospital in St. Paul shortly after MNA’s strike began on Labor Day.

Thousands of Allina nurses and their supporters are spending Labor Day on the picket line, as members of the Minnesota Nurses Association today began an open-ended strike at five Twin Cities facilities.

For the second time this summer, union nurses at United, Abbott Northwestern, Mercy and Unity hospitals and Phillips Eye Institute walked off the job and onto the picket lines, this time in an open-ended strike. Allina nurses staged a seven-day strike at the same facilities in June.

Negotiations on a contract covering nearly 5,000 Allina nurses began in February, and since then the health provider has refused to budge from its demand for steep concessions from nurses on the issue of health insurance. Nurses say Allina negotiators will not even discuss their top priorities – issues like workplace safety and staffing for quality patient care – until they give up their quality, affordable insurance.

At a federally mediated, 22-hour bargaining session that stretched into the early-morning hours Saturday, nurses agreed to phase out their insurance and enter Allina’s preferred plans. But Allina balked at language guaranteeing nurses’ health benefits would not be cut or diminished during the life of the contract, as well as the union’s request to verify the value of Allina insurance plans with independent accountants.

Bunny Engeldorf, a nurse at United Hospital and member of the MNA negotiations team, called Allina’s refusal to compromise disrespectful to nurses.

“It seems like money and control are the only two issues they care about,” Engeldorf said. “We went to the table to talk about staffing and workplace safety, and they went to the table to talk about taking away our health insurance.”

No new negotiation dates have been set, and nurses say they will picket all five Allina facilities, from 7 a.m. to 7 p.m., until a settlement is reached. [Click for a list of ways you can support Allina nurses in their open-ended strike.]

Angela Becchetti, a nurse at Abbott Northwestern Hospital and union spokesperson, said she thought the two sides were close to a settlement before Allina walked away from the table, noting progress on issues like 24-hour security in emergency rooms and allowing new nurses into the union health plans for a limited time.

“Just like a bully, Allina demanded nurses give up their affordable health insurance plans, and when we agreed to phase them out, they wanted more,” Becchetti said.

Teachers, clergy, public employees, elected officials and other supporters walked the picket line alongside nurses at United Hospital this morning. Several unions have delivered notice to Allina of their intent to picket, and delivery drivers reportedly were refusing to drive their vehicles past nurses’ picket lines.

“Nurses are fighting for their own health care, and it’s important that the people who take care of us have the best health care available,” Rep. Tim Mahoney, a retired member of St. Paul Pipefitters Local 455, said from the picket line. “After learning how far the nurses have moved (in negotiations), for Allina to say no to those particulars and force these people out on strike is unconscionable.”

Several picketers, including Rep. Erin Murphy, said the outpouring of solidarity was a poignant reminder of the true meaning of Labor Day.

“Labor Day recognizes all those who came before us who fought for fair working conditions,” said Murphy, who is a registered nurse. “But this is not a fight in our history, it’s a fight that continues into the future, and it’s appropriate that we’re here today on Labor Day.”