Study finds taxpayers subsidize big-box stores at cost of $150 million per year in Minnesota

blackfriday-sign3-web

Black Friday protests last year drew more than 200 people to the Midway Walmart in St. Paul.

Retail workers and activists who join the protest outside Walmart in St. Paul on Black Friday will be armed with a scathing new report shedding light on the public cost of poverty-level wages paid by Walmart, Target and other big-box department stores.

“At What Cost,” released Nov. 12 by the union-backed Minnesotans for a Fair Economy, reveals how Minnesota taxpayers, by picking up the cost of basic necessities thousands of retail workers can’t afford, are subsidizing big-box stores’ low wages.

“We estimate that over 20,000 big-box department store workers in Minnesota are enrolled in some form of public assistance program, either for themselves or family members, at a cost of over $150 million a year to taxpayers,” the report says.

[Click here to RSVP for Black Friday protests in the Twin Cities on Facebook!]

Not surprisingly, the majority of retail workers accessing safety-net programs for themselves or their families come from Walmart and Target. The report estimates 5,850 Target workers in Minnesota access public assistance at an annual cost to taxpayers of $44.7 million, while 5,311 Walmart employees statewide seek about $40.6 million in public assistance annually.

That these two retailers are the worst offenders is hardly surprising, considering the wages paid in their stores.

The average hourly wage of a Walmart sales associate, according to the report, is $8.81, while the average pay for Target’s frontline staff ranges from $8.10 per hour for cashiers to $8.34 per hour for “team members” on the sales floor.

A full-time worker earning those wages wouldn’t sniff the federal poverty line, which explains why so many turn to food stamps and other safety-net programs to support themselves and their families. What’s worse, over half of retail workers are “involuntarily part-time,” making it even harder to make ends meet without public assistance.

The public cost of health care for big-box store workers, meanwhile, is particularly taxing. Roughly half of Walmart associates and a third of Target “team members” are enrolled in the companies’ health insurance plans. Workers “say that the health plans are too expensive or inaccessible,” according to the report.

The report provides the first local look at findings introduced by Democrats on the U.S. House Committee on Education and the Workforce in May.

Analyzing Medicaid data, the committee report found that a single 300-employee Walmart Supercenter in Wisconsin cost taxpayers between $900,000 and $1.75 million per year – or roughly $5,815 per employee.

At the conclusion of “At What Cost,” the authors offer three suggestions for reducing the strain on public assistance created by big-box retailers, particularly Target and Walmart.

Big-box retailers should pay a living wage of $14.41 per hour, state lawmakers in Minnesota should raise the minimum wage to $9.50 per hour and, the report says, retailers should “stop interfering with their employees’ rights to speak out for better jobs.”

“Big-box retail employers could listen to their employees’ calls for change, rather than retaliate against them for speaking out.”

Taxpayers are subsidizing fast-food industry’s low wages, report finds

Activists pass out fliers highlighting the findings of a new report on the public cost of fast-food wages outside a Minneapolis Wendy's restaurant.

Outside a Minneapolis Wendy’s, activists pass out fliers highlighting a new report on the public cost of fast-food wages.

That extra value meal might seem like a bargain, but a new report shows low prices on the fast-food menu come at a high cost to U.S. taxpayers.

How much? Nearly $7 billion a year.

That’s the cost of public assistance for fast-food workers and their families, according to “Fast Food, Poverty Wages,” a report released Tuesday by researchers from the University of California, Berkeley and the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign.

The report undermines industry-backed stereotypes of fast-food workers as teenagers gaining valuable employment experience, or students mixing part-time work into their busy schedules.

In reality, fast-food workers are more likely to be parents than to be living with their parents. Most are adults for whom “fast-food wages are an essential component of family income,” according to the report, which looked at “core” workers – those logging 10 hours or more per week, at least 27 weeks out of the year on the industry’s front lines.

The industry’s low wages, coupled with its approach to scheduling, mean people working fast-food jobs are more likely than other workers to live in or near poverty, the report found. The median hourly wage for core, front-line workers in the industry is $8.69, and the median number of hours worked is 30 per week. Only 13 percent receive health benefits through their employer.

With basic needs like food, shelter and health care out of reach, 52 percent of front-line fast-food workers seek public assistance for themselves or their families. Medicaid, the Earned Income Tax Credit, the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) and Temporary Aid for Needy Families (TANF) are “indispensible programs” for fast-food workers, according to the researchers.

‘Unacceptable and unsustainable’

To activists who demonstrated outside the Wendy’s restaurant off Lake Street and Hiawatha Avenue in Minneapolis on Tuesday, the new report was more evidence that taxpayers are picking up the social costs of fast-food companies’ low wages and staggering profits.

“Fast food companies like Wendy’s have accumulated profits in the billions of dollars, yet they are saying they can’t afford to do more for their workers,” said Carol Nieters, executive director of Service Employees International Union Local 284.

SEIU members joined forces with the community outreach organization Minnesotans for a Fair Economy to stage the demonstration. Activists waved leaflets at cars exiting the Wendy’s drive-through, and they talked to customers about the findings of “Fast Food, Poverty Wages,” the findings of which, Nieters said, highlighted a “sad moment in our nation’s history.”

Rev. Grant Stevensen, a pastor at St. Matthew’s Lutheran Church in St. Paul, joined the protest out of concern not just for fast-food workers, but also for franchise owners, who are being “squeezed more and more by the parent company,” he said.

“We are tied together as a patchwork in this country,” Stevensen said. “Whether we rise or we fall, we do that together. It is imperative the faith community be involved in this call for justice because we don’t have to live this way. We can create a different future that works for everybody.”

Raise the wage!

Both Stevenson and Nieters pointed to the report as more evidence to support raising the minimum wage at both the state and federal levels. The Minnesota Legislature is likely to take up a minimum-wage bill during the 2014 session, and labor, faith and progressive groups have formed a coalition planning to push a $9.50-per-hour minimum wage.

Authors of the report agree: Stronger minimum-wage laws would go a long way toward bridging the gap between fast-food workers’ wages and their basic needs, while easing the burden on taxpayer-funded programs.

“The results of this report suggest (public assistance) programs would be more effective if they were combined with measures to improve wages and health benefits among low-wage workers,” the report says. “Many fast-food workers earn close to the minimum wage and would benefit from an increase in the minimum wage or through targeted local laws to raise labor standards.”

The report also notes that “very few fast-food restaurants have collective bargaining agreements,” which would “increase wage and benefits standards” in the industry.

One thing Nieters knows for sure is fast-food companies won’t increase wages and benefits for their workers without public pressure. “Corporations like Wendy’s will not do more for their workers because it’s the right thing to do,” she said.

Click here to add your name to a petition in support of raising Minnesota’s minimum wage to $9.50 by 2015.

Rev. Grant Stevensen and SEIU Local 284 Executive Director Carol Nieters speak to activists outside a Wendy's in Minneapolis.

Rev. Grant Stevensen and SEIU Local 284 Executive Director Carol Nieters speak to activists outside a Wendy’s in Minneapolis.